A winter in Smolensk, a sixth coalition TL

Part 10-The fight for Smolensk, phase one
By mid October, the French position in Russian was grim, and now the noose began to tighten. As Chichagov moved on the main road into Russia, Smolensk had its lines of communication cut on October 15th. Bessiéres and Ney were already on the move, and their 50,000 men were rested and decently fed, arriving in Minsk on the 22nd after a 12 day forced march. Here he met up with the exhausted but relatively intact Austrian corps, Schwarzenberg having fallen back due to being outnumbered.

Chichagov and his 60,000 men were now outnumbered, but for once the French had intelligence on their side. While Bessiéres had been hounded by Cossacks all the way, these reported to Kutuzov, and so Chichagov was often out of the loop on reports. He believed that Poniatowski was still in Smolensk, and so didn't expect as large a force. This, combined with an overestimation of French attrition, meant he marched into the fight overconfident and clueless. Bessiéres was little better, while he'd marched the men hard and managed to maintain discipline and morale, his shortcomings as an army commander were made more clear. As Berthier wrote to the emperor "He's about as skilled at commanding your army as I was, I see my faults plainly in him. He's reactive, indecisive, and his orders are more unclear than your majesties.

After a pause to rest and reorganize, the French army moved to confront Chichagov. At the village of Ozero, the two armies met for battle on the morning of the 26th. (Author's note: Wanted to include a google earth shot of the otl location, but it said the file was too big. Just look up Ozero, Belarus) The ground was flat and barren, the land deserted and picked over. Chichagov formed up his line west of the village, anchoring his left flank on the river Zhest, and his right on a pond next to Ozero. Bessiéres positioned his army on some light hills and villages to the North

Battle of Ozero order of battle, West to East​


Army of the Danube: Adm Chichagov​

2nd Corps: Gen Esssen​

4th Corps: Gen Bulatov​

1st Corps: Gen Langeron​

3rd Corps: Gen Voinov​

200 Guns​


Grande Armée: MdE Bessiéres​


V Corps: Gen Poniatowski​

Austrian Corps: Gen Schwarzenberg​

III Corps: MdE Ney​

Cavalry: Gen Grouchy​

II Cav Corps: Gen Nansouty​

I Cav Corps: Gen Montbrun​

269 Guns​


The battle began around 10am, as Chichagov began his attack on what he still believed was a smaller French force. The attack was pooly coordinated, as he gave each corps individual orders to attack, leading to delay. Worse still, his orders on where to attack were muddled and subjective, causing 2nd and 4th Corps to essentially march into eachother, right as they entered the French artillery range. Despite this setback, the Russians soon began a fierce attack against the French line.

Bessiéres wasn't doing much better, despite his numbers and position. He wanted to smash the Russians decisively, but went about it shoddily. His orders resulted in Ney and Schwarzenberg advancing off the high ground, right into the range of the Russians. Casualties were high on boths sides, as both commanders seemed to freeze up, letting their subordinates take charge. As the fighting progressed, by noon the French were advancing, but at a high cost. Ironically despite being a cavalryman himself Bessiéres made no initial attempt to use his cavalry, and Grouchy was left in the read for much of the day.

Finally, without waiting for orders, Grouchy led a charge with Nansouty's Corps on the Russian left. Chichagov's men were some if the most experienced in Russia, but even they began to waver. Chichagov ordered a general retreat, but again the orders led to disaster. With no proper rearguard, Langeron's corps was rolled up and all but destroyed by Ney. Bessiéres ordered a persuit with his remaining cavalry, and managed to inflict many more casualties on the fleeing enemy.

The battle of Ozero had been a confused, messy battle, with incompetance on both sides. The French lost around 20,000 casualties in the battle, to around 30,000 Russians (Of which 10,000 were prisoners). The fighting was as savage as Borodino, and the soldiers were not happy with their generals. "The battle of the blunderers" as it became known to soldiers on both sides, was as Ney said "The most asinine display of soldiering I ever saw.". Bessiéres would remain in Minsk, while to the East, more battles raged.
 
By mid October, the French position in Russian was grim, and now the noose began to tighten. As Chichagov moved on the main road into Russia, Smolensk had its lines of communication cut on October 15th. Bessiéres and Ney were already on the move, and their 50,000 men were rested and decently fed, arriving in Minsk on the 22nd after a 12 day forced march. Here he met up with the exhausted but relatively intact Austrian corps, Schwarzenberg having fallen back due to being outnumbered.

Chichagov and his 60,000 men were now outnumbered, but for once the French had intelligence on their side. While Bessiéres had been hounded by Cossacks all the way, these reported to Kutuzov, and so Chichagov was often out of the loop on reports. He believed that Poniatowski was still in Smolensk, and so didn't expect as large a force. This, combined with an overestimation of French attrition, meant he marched into the fight overconfident and clueless. Bessiéres was little better, while he'd marched the men hard and managed to maintain discipline and morale, his shortcomings as an army commander were made more clear. As Berthier wrote to the emperor "He's about as skilled at commanding your army as I was, I see my faults plainly in him. He's reactive, indecisive, and his orders are more unclear than your majesties.

After a pause to rest and reorganize, the French army moved to confront Chichagov. At the village of Ozero, the two armies met for battle on the morning of the 26th. (Author's note: Wanted to include a google earth shot of the otl location, but it said the file was too big. Just look up Ozero, Belarus) The ground was flat and barren, the land deserted and picked over. Chichagov formed up his line west of the village, anchoring his left flank on the river Zhest, and his right on a pond next to Ozero. Bessiéres positioned his army on some light hills and villages to the North

Battle of Ozero order of battle, West to East​


Army of the Danube: Adm Chichagov​

2nd Corps: Gen Esssen​

4th Corps: Gen Bulatov​

1st Corps: Gen Langeron​

3rd Corps: Gen Voinov​

200 Guns​


Grande Armée: MdE Bessiéres​


V Corps: Gen Poniatowski​

Austrian Corps: Gen Schwarzenberg​

III Corps: MdE Ney​

Cavalry: Gen Grouchy​

II Cav Corps: Gen Nansouty​

I Cav Corps: Gen Montbrun​

269 Guns​


The battle began around 10am, as Chichagov began his attack on what he still believed was a smaller French force. The attack was pooly coordinated, as he gave each corps individual orders to attack, leading to delay. Worse still, his orders on where to attack were muddled and subjective, causing 2nd and 4th Corps to essentially march into eachother, right as they entered the French artillery range. Despite this setback, the Russians soon began a fierce attack against the French line.

Bessiéres wasn't doing much better, despite his numbers and position. He wanted to smash the Russians decisively, but went about it shoddily. His orders resulted in Ney and Schwarzenberg advancing off the high ground, right into the range of the Russians. Casualties were high on boths sides, as both commanders seemed to freeze up, letting their subordinates take charge. As the fighting progressed, by noon the French were advancing, but at a high cost. Ironically despite being a cavalryman himself Bessiéres made no initial attempt to use his cavalry, and Grouchy was left in the read for much of the day.

Finally, without waiting for orders, Grouchy led a charge with Nansouty's Corps on the Russian left. Chichagov's men were some if the most experienced in Russia, but even they began to waver. Chichagov ordered a general retreat, but again the orders led to disaster. With no proper rearguard, Langeron's corps was rolled up and all but destroyed by Ney. Bessiéres ordered a persuit with his remaining cavalry, and managed to inflict many more casualties on the fleeing enemy.

The battle of Ozero had been a confused, messy battle, with incompetance on both sides. The French lost around 20,000 casualties in the battle, to around 30,000 Russians (Of which 10,000 were prisoners). The fighting was as savage as Borodino, and the soldiers were not happy with their generals. "The battle of the blunderers" as it became known to soldiers on both sides, was as Ney said "The most asinine display of soldiering I ever saw.". Bessiéres would remain in Minsk, while to the East, more battles raged.
1690631813300.jpeg



1690631855821.png

Top - the old military map, below - more modern (Озеро). Hopefully, will help a little bit.

1690632760390.jpeg

This is the whole area with Ozero on the very top.
 
Last edited:
The Fight for Smolensk, phase two
Marshal Mortier and General Junot left Smolensk on the 12th of October, with the goal of delaying Kutuzov. Kutuzov himself left Vyazma on the 10th, though his advance was much slower. The depleated Westphalian and Italian Corps numbered just 28,000 men, against 95,000 Russians. Kutuzov was well informed of Mortier's movements, but a misunderstanding in geography led him to believe the enemy was lagging a day behind where they actually were. Mortier had a much harder time with reconnaissance due to his shortage of Cavalry, but on the night of the 18th got lucky. Some of his light cavalry almost stumbled into the Russian camp at the town of Yartsevo, who hadn't realized how close Mortier was. Leading the men through the night, they fell upon the Russian sentries at dawn.

The Russians reacted slowly, Kutuzov wasn't even awoken until a 15 minutes after the ambush began. General Barclay, who was awake, realized that defending the camp would be folly, and had the men withdraw across the Reka Vop. Despite being under heavy artillery fire, Italian Velites looted the Russian camp, stealing horses and food, and spiking 60 guns. As Kutuzov realized the situation he had the Imperial guard cross the river, while ordering all the cavalry to outflank the enemy. By 10am the Russian and French allied armies were arriving on the West bank of the river in force, but the Russians were three times as large. Realizing that he wasn't likely to acheive much else, Mortier began the retreat.

The Cossacks were merciless in their pursuit, which in turn led to heavy casualties for the horsemen as the Italians and Germans formed square and absorbed the attack. At 11:30 in the final moments of the battle, General Junot leading the men and defending a square, was shot by friendly fire in the confused mass of and horses. Barclay had wanted their infantry to pursue as well, but Kutuzov refused, fearing they were too low on ammunition. Casualties were light, about 2,000 Italo-Germans to 5,000 Russians, though the Russians lost 2/3rds of their ammo.

Months later, Napoleon gave Junot the unique honor of a posthumous promotion to Marshal, as well as the title Prince of Yartsevo. The Russians stayed another week in Yartsevo, despite pleas from Barclay and increasingly furious letters from Tsar Alexander. At the slow pace of the Russian advance, the tsar finally removed Kutuzov, and handed his rule over to Barclay. After a moment to reorganize he sent out a series of commands to his new subordinates, he had a plan. Wittgenstein and Chichagov would advance to tie up the French reserve, while Barclay's own force charged into Smolensk. The Grandé Armée would be isolated and destroyed, and their would be nothing between them and Berlin or Vienna. The next battles would be some of the most brutal, and savage of the entire Napoleonic wars.
 
The Fight for Smolensk, phase three
The week the Russians stayed at Yartsevo was enough for Bessiéres to be informed of the situation, but not long enough to send any forces back. Leaving Ney in command of his Western forces, the Marshal personally rode to Smolensk to help defend the city. Barclay, who took command of all Russisn forces on October 25th, immediately had his army march on Smolensk, believing Mortier's was the only enemy force between him and the city. This wasn't strictly true however.

Marshal Saint Cyr and his Bavarian VI Corps had been garrisoned in the city, about 17,000 strong. Additionally, about 10,000 or so surviving members of the Imperial guard had been stationed there to recuperate after the losses at Borodino. Between this and Mortiers troops, the French had about 53,000 men and 400 guns, facing nearly 100,000 russians and 600 guns. Saint Cyr hadn't been idle in his position however, and had spent the last few weeks preparing for a possible siege. Rationing was strictly enforced, the fortress guns were put into position, and earthworks constructed outside the walls.

Smolensk itself was a fortress town, and was surrounded by a solid medieval wall. The battle in August had caused some damage, but the northern section (Which the Russians were approaching) was largely intact. Saint Cyr had planned to keep most of his troops outside the walls, and Bessiéres agreed when he arrived.
smolenskmaps.jpg

(Map of the August battl
Barclay didn't plan on laying siege, however. He planned to smash through Smolensk's walls, and rout the French, forcing them to retreat across open country, or die trying. That being so his advance was "Bagrationesque" as Saint Cyr himself said, advancing on Smolensk in just two days. Bessiéres arrived on the 26th, just a day ahead of the Russians. Wanting to force Barclay into engaging, the marshal had Mortier and what was left of the Westphalians positioned outside the Northern wall.

On the morning of the 27th, General Platov's Cossacks arrived on the outskirts of the city. Bessiéres personally led the guard cavalry and any surviving horsemen to confront them, and a skirmish broke out. The French soon retreated and the Cossacks chased them towards Smolensk. As they approached the city, the Cossacks came under massive fire from Mortier's Italians. Having entrenched themselves and from hidden positions in the buildings of Smolensk, they inflicted terrible losses on the Russians, who pulled out of town to wait for Barclay to arrive.

As he did so around Noon, Barclay ordered three infantry corps to attack the city, and had his guns open fire on the walls. For once however, the Russian weather was on the side of the French. A miserable cold rain began, turning the approaches to Smolensk to mud. The Russian attackers slammed into the Italo-German positions, but they held on. French artillery poured into the Russian collumns, but they continued to advance nonetheless. Mortier led his men in counterattack, being wounded twice as his men gradually yielded ground.

The walls of Smolensk held up against the Russian field guns, and now chasseurs of the old guard used them, raining fire down on the enemy infantry. Finally as the Russian guards joined the attack, the French allies routed, streaming back into the city. As the enemy forces pursued, Saint Cyr and Bessiéres led the Bavarian corps and the guard in a massive melee, both sides struggling to control the Northern gate. Russian horse artillery and French fortress guns exchanged canister shot at point blank range, shot and shrapnal pouring into the troops of both sides.

The fighting continued until dark, as the Russians slowly worked their way through the city house by house, each one made into another battle hy the french. As darkness fell and the French looked to be massing for a counterattack, Barclay finally bowed to the inevitable and ordered a retreat. Without the numbers to properly siege such a fortress, Barclay instead had his army make camp just outside the city, hoping to chase them down should a retreat be attempted. Losses were heavy on both sides, 15,000 French to 25,000 Russians, with many wounded falling to malnutrition, disease, or the cold.

Wittgenstein attacked a day later at Polotsk, and drove out French. Marshal Oudinot was blown off his horse by a shell, smashing his head on a cannon. He survived but was seeiously concussed, and he and Marshal Victor began a retreat to Smolensk. With winter coming and neither side backing down, the campaign's greatest trials lay ahead...
 
Part 11-Planning Planning and More Planning

Tuileries Palace, November 1st, 1812​


"Right now, Moncey, Kellermann, what's the story?" The men poured through their papers in one frantic moment, before the elder Kellermann finally cleared his throat to speak "Well training of the conscripts in going well, considering most of them are young enough to be my great grandchildren" Napoleon smirked "That's not saying much anymore is it?" "No sire." chuckled the old marshal. "In any case, desertions have been minimal, and despite most of them being right outside Paris and Mainz, there hasn't been much in the way of misbehavior." "Good good" Napoleon nodded "Morale?" "Holding up better than I hoped, I think seeing your majesty's together very much inspired them."

Napoleon smiled at that "I heard the recruits have started calling themselves Marie-Louise's, true?" "Well I did sign the laws that put them in uniform" His wife smiled "Plus..." Butted in Moncey "They're young and raw, much like your.." The Empress blushed, and the Emperor scowled at Moncey "Anyway... The national guard conversions are going well. Their march discipline is terrible, but they'll fight like demons should they get the chance." "Hmm..." Napoleon once again got lost in his labyrinth of a mind. "Good, this is good. Clarke, give me a full tally."

The Minister of War wrote something down "Looks like between the guard and the Marie-Louises, we should have 200,000 men ready to march by spring, and another 150 by summer. That's in addition to 20,000 from Spain, and 15,000 marines." "Not bad" Napoleon remarked "Not bad at all. Old Alexander will have his head spin when he sees what I've created." Clarke looked down "Sire, do you really think it wise to cling to Smolensk like this?" "Leave strategy to me Clarke, there's a reason you're commanding a chair." Bonaparte said bluntly "Bessiéres is smart, he'll hold out till the sun dies if I command it."

Meanwhile in Smolensk...​


"I think we need to withdraw from Smolensk." Marshal Bessiéres said to the assembled men. Not only had Bethier followed him to join Mortier and Saint Cyr, but Davout had arrived from his position in the South, while Oudinot had returned to the city to recover from his concussion, which was an ongoing process. Saint Cyr nodded "Agreed, Minsk is far more secure. As it is we're dangling our ass over the fire." Mortier stood "But the Emperor made his orders very clear, we were to winter in Smolensk"

"And the Emperor isn't here. If we withdraw now, we can hold out in Minsk with little trouble. If we wait, we'll have to retreat through the worst cold you'll ever find in Europe." "What we really need to do!" Oudinot slurred "Is get some tanks!" Everyone stared at the man "I serve the Soviet Union, and we need our tanks!" Bessiéres broke the silence "Nicholas, what the fuck are you talking about?" "I'm talking about crushing the nazi's!!! You damn Balt!" "Ok..." Mortier said "Go see Doctor Larrey, you need to lie down." Oudinot nodded, did a Roman salute, and marched out of the room "What the hell is a tank?" quipped Davout "No clue, anyway does anyone object, on any grounds besides going against his Majesty's orders?" Nobody spoke "Right then, we march in three days." Outside, it began to snow heavily...
 
I see Oudinot has become an asb
Marshal Oudinot’s many wounds over many years and his recovery from them almost seems ASB as well. But given the absolutely, indisputably true facts of his injuries and recoveries (See The Indestructible General -- Marshal Nicolas Oudinot), I don’t think it is inconceivable that he could have hallucinated some extraordinary figments of the imagination. Parmenion has certainly deployed a unique and interesting twist.

BTW Parmenion, your maps are greatly appreciated.
 
Interesting TL...
"Not bad at all. Old Alexander will have his head spin when he sees what I've created."
The matter, imo, would be that the time and the distances involved from Napoleon Armies training and staging/concentration place in Western Europe, may appear that are running in favor of the Russians...
Bonaparte said bluntly "Bessiéres is smart, he'll hold out till the sun dies if I command it."
"No clue, anyway does anyone object, on any grounds besides going against his Majesty's orders?" Nobody spoke "Right then, we march in three days." Outside, it began to snow heavily...
Well, would appears that supposing that no courier reach them, reaffirming them their sovereign direct orders, that the French Grand Armee remnants either have a very big chance to get destroyed while attempting to reach Minsk or they get to starring in an nineteenth century Napoleonic Stalingrad level disaster...
 

Tuileries Palace, November 1st, 1812​


"Right now, Moncey, Kellermann, what's the story?" The men poured through their papers in one frantic moment, before the elder Kellermann finally cleared his throat to speak "Well training of the conscripts in going well, considering most of them are young enough to be my great grandchildren" Napoleon smirked "That's not saying much anymore is it?" "No sire." chuckled the old marshal. "In any case, desertions have been minimal, and despite most of them being right outside Paris and Mainz, there hasn't been much in the way of misbehavior." "Good good" Napoleon nodded "Morale?" "Holding up better than I hoped, I think seeing your majesty's together very much inspired them."

Napoleon smiled at that "I heard the recruits have started calling themselves Marie-Louise's, true?" "Well I did sign the laws that put them in uniform" His wife smiled "Plus..." Butted in Moncey "They're young and raw, much like your.." The Empress blushed, and the Emperor scowled at Moncey "Anyway... The national guard conversions are going well. Their march discipline is terrible, but they'll fight like demons should they get the chance." "Hmm..." Napoleon once again got lost in his labyrinth of a mind. "Good, this is good. Clarke, give me a full tally."

The Minister of War wrote something down "Looks like between the guard and the Marie-Louises, we should have 200,000 men ready to march by spring, and another 150 by summer. That's in addition to 20,000 from Spain, and 15,000 marines." "Not bad" Napoleon remarked "Not bad at all. Old Alexander will have his head spin when he sees what I've created." Clarke looked down "Sire, do you really think it wise to cling to Smolensk like this?" "Leave strategy to me Clarke, there's a reason you're commanding a chair." Bonaparte said bluntly "Bessiéres is smart, he'll hold out till the sun dies if I command it."

Meanwhile in Smolensk...​


"I think we need to withdraw from Smolensk." Marshal Bessiéres said to the assembled men. Not only had Bethier followed him to join Mortier and Saint Cyr, but Davout had arrived from his position in the South, while Oudinot had returned to the city to recover from his concussion, which was an ongoing process. Saint Cyr nodded "Agreed, Minsk is far more secure. As it is we're dangling our ass over the fire." Mortier stood "But the Emperor made his orders very clear, we were to winter in Smolensk"

"And the Emperor isn't here. If we withdraw now, we can hold out in Minsk with little trouble. If we wait, we'll have to retreat through the worst cold you'll ever find in Europe." "What we really need to do!" Oudinot slurred "Is get some tanks!" Everyone stared at the man "I serve the Soviet Union, and we need our tanks!" Bessiéres broke the silence "Nicholas, what the fuck are you talking about?" "I'm talking about crushing the nazi's!!! You damn Balt!" "Ok..." Mortier said "Go see Doctor Larrey, you need to lie down." Oudinot nodded, did a Roman salute, and marched out of the room "What the hell is a tank?" quipped Davout "No clue, anyway does anyone object, on any grounds besides going against his Majesty's orders?" Nobody spoke "Right then, we march in three days." Outside, it began to snow heavily...
This comic relief is just great! But if he got THAT advanced in time, he would know that what he need is not the tanks. I’m referencing to the old Soviet joke about Napoleon reading the Soviet official newspaper “Pravda”: “If I had a newspaper like that, nobody would learn about Waterloo!” 😂
 
The week the Russians stayed at Yartsevo was enough for Bessiéres to be informed of the situation, but not long enough to send any forces back. Leaving Ney in command of his Western forces, the Marshal personally rode to Smolensk to help defend the city. Barclay, who took command of all Russisn forces on October 25th, immediately had his army march on Smolensk, believing Mortier's was the only enemy force between him and the city. This wasn't strictly true however.

Marshal Saint Cyr and his Bavarian VI Corps had been garrisoned in the city, about 17,000 strong. Additionally, about 10,000 or so surviving members of the Imperial guard had been stationed there to recuperate after the losses at Borodino. Between this and Mortiers troops, the French had about 53,000 men and 400 guns, facing nearly 100,000 russians and 600 guns. Saint Cyr hadn't been idle in his position however, and had spent the last few weeks preparing for a possible siege. Rationing was strictly enforced, the fortress guns were put into position, and earthworks constructed outside the walls.

Smolensk itself was a fortress town, and was surrounded by a solid medieval wall. The battle in August had caused some damage, but the northern section (Which the Russians were approaching) was largely intact. Saint Cyr had planned to keep most of his troops outside the walls, and Bessiéres agreed when he arrived.
smolenskmaps.jpg

(Map of the August battl
Barclay didn't plan on laying siege, however. He planned to smash through Smolensk's walls, and rout the French, forcing them to retreat across open country, or die trying. That being so his advance was "Bagrationesque" as Saint Cyr himself said, advancing on Smolensk in just two days. Bessiéres arrived on the 26th, just a day ahead of the Russians. Wanting to force Barclay into engaging, the marshal had Mortier and what was left of the Westphalians positioned outside the Northern wall.

On the morning of the 27th, General Platov's Cossacks arrived on the outskirts of the city. Bessiéres personally led the guard cavalry and any surviving horsemen to confront them, and a skirmish broke out. The French soon retreated and the Cossacks chased them towards Smolensk. As they approached the city, the Cossacks came under massive fire from Mortier's Italians. Having entrenched themselves and from hidden positions in the buildings of Smolensk, they inflicted terrible losses on the Russians, who pulled out of town to wait for Barclay to arrive.

As he did so around Noon, Barclay ordered three infantry corps to attack the city, and had his guns open fire on the walls. For once however, the Russian weather was on the side of the French. A miserable cold rain began, turning the approaches to Smolensk to mud. The Russian attackers slammed into the Italo-German positions, but they held on. French artillery poured into the Russian collumns, but they continued to advance nonetheless. Mortier led his men in counterattack, being wounded twice as his men gradually yielded ground.

The walls of Smolensk held up against the Russian field guns, and now chasseurs of the old guard used them, raining fire down on the enemy infantry. Finally as the Russian guards joined the attack, the French allies routed, streaming back into the city. As the enemy forces pursued, Saint Cyr and Bessiéres led the Bavarian corps and the guard in a massive melee, both sides struggling to control the Northern gate. Russian horse artillery and French fortress guns exchanged canister shot at point blank range, shot and shrapnal pouring into the troops of both sides.

The fighting continued until dark, as the Russians slowly worked their way through the city house by house, each one made into another battle hy the french. As darkness fell and the French looked to be massing for a counterattack, Barclay finally bowed to the inevitable and ordered a retreat. Without the numbers to properly siege such a fortress, Barclay instead had his army make camp just outside the city, hoping to chase them down should a retreat be attempted. Losses were heavy on both sides, 15,000 French to 25,000 Russians, with many wounded falling to malnutrition, disease, or the cold.

Wittgenstein attacked a day later at Polotsk, and drove out French. Marshal Oudinot was blown off his horse by a shell, smashing his head on a cannon. He survived but was seeiously concussed, and he and Marshal Victor began a retreat to Smolensk. With winter coming and neither side backing down, the campaign's greatest trials lay ahead...
Very interesting, as usual, but I have two questions:

1. With the Russians already losing many tens of thousands after Borodino and not having time to bring in the new troops (they are still in training), where these 100,000 came from?

2. Sorry, but I did not quite get how the Smolensk thing works out. As you can see from the map, there is only a small tete-de-pont on the left bank of the Dnieper. Only a very limited number of troops could be placed to defend it and Barclay, with his experience and knowledge of the city would not order to use the field guns to break the wall: this would be a patently useless exercise (see wall fragment below).
1691111507830.jpeg

The field howitzers probably could be able to shoot the explosive shells over the wall making defenders life miserable and forcing them to retreat across the river.
1691111372640.png

But at that point the Russians still would have (a) to break the gates, (b) to cross the river, with the defenders having plenty of time to break the bridges and (c) after this is done to scale the northern wall for which exercise they’d need the ladders. Wouldn’t it be more sensible to cross with the main force river downstream and march to the South of the city (Nikolskoe suburb) threatening the encirclement? The French would have either to abandon the city in a haste or to stay in it being surrounded. Barclay, judging by his record, was not a butcher-style general and scenario of a headlong attack of the fortified city from the march and across the river seems to be a little bit too much… But perhaps he had aviation? 😜


As a nitpicking thingy, don’t suck up to the French-inspired depictions of the Cossacks’ activities. Being a light irregular cavalry, they were not expected to fight a regular cavalry in an orderly formation. Encounters during summer campaign of 1812 usually involved the “asiatic tactics” of provoking the opponents into a disorderly pursuit with a following ambush. The only exception were Life Cossacks of the Imperial Guards. And BTW, not too many Cossacks had been present at the 1812 campaign: the French simply put into this category pretty much any light cavalry they encountered outside of a battlefield. 😉
 
Love that I'm getting extensive criticism, I really need that so thanks. (Sorry if that sounds sarcastic, it's not)

1) From my understanding the Russian army OTL under Kutuzov did recieve a few reinforcements after abandoning Moscow, so this is just that, plus maybe some militia and irregulars joining in.

2). Ok here, ya got me, I honestly didn't have a proper understanding of the defences of Smolensk. Basically what I was trying to potray was this. The Russians attack the left bank and manage to throw back the French with heavy loses, but the French rout is enough that they're able to just bumrush the gates and enter that way, it's just Bessiéres and Saint Cyr are able to rally them before the city falls completely. As for why he doesn't go around, it's not that Barclay is a butcher, it's just that he's trying to take the city before any French reinforcements arrive, and that would be the quickest way.
 
Love that I'm getting extensive criticism, I really need that so thanks. (Sorry if that sounds sarcastic, it's not)
I’m not “criticizing” - this implies a negative attitude and I like your TL. I’m just giving my opinions, which are not mandatory for you. As far as the narrative goes, these details are not of a vital importance.

1) From my understanding the Russian army OTL under Kutuzov did recieve a few reinforcements after abandoning Moscow, so this is just that, plus maybe some militia and irregulars joining in.
AFAIK, “yes and no”. They were staying in Tarutino camp for 3 weeks (September 21 - October 11) during which time the numbers grew either from 85,000 to 120,000 or from 60,000 to 130,000. There were troops in training from the spring conscription of 1812 and those conscripted in August (IIRC) but, AFAIK, Kutuzov refused to use them, claiming that they are not trained enough. Taking into the account prevailing attitudes, I suspect that this opinion was universally shared (AFAIK, nobody blamed him for this).
Militia was not a fighting force (at Borodino it was used only for digging fortifications and perhaps picking the wounded) and the closest irregulars would have to ride all the way from Don.
In this TL you seemingly don’t have these three weeks to get rest and reinforcements, the losses at Borodino are much higher than in OTL and there was already one post-Borodino battle in which they suffered very high losses. Plus, they’ll need fresh horses, artillery, gunpowder, shells, etc.

2). Ok here, ya got me, I honestly didn't have a proper understanding of the defences of Smolensk.

The walls had been old but they had a good anti-artillery construction which was still effective in 1812. The reasonably soft outer layer was “absorbing” the shells with a minimal damage and the hard stones inside were stopping them.
Basically what I was trying to potray was this. The Russians attack the left bank and manage to throw back the French with heavy loses, but the French rout is enough that they're able to just bumrush the gates and enter that way, it's just Bessiéres and Saint Cyr are able to rally them before the city falls completely. As for why he doesn't go around, it's not that Barclay is a butcher, it's just that he's trying to take the city before any French reinforcements arrive, and that would be the quickest way.
Well, your intention is understandable but putting all forces into the tete-de-pont attack does not serve this intention (this is just my opinion):
  1. You simply can’t effectively deploy 100,000 troops against perimeter less than 1,000 meters long, so Barclay would have plenty of forces to attack elsewhere.
  2. Attack on the left bank does not serve any purpose because bulk of the enemy forces and the city are on the other bank of a reasonably big river and behind the wall. Even if by some crazy reason the retreating defenders of tete-de-pont are not destroying the (wooden) bridges, the attackers are still facing the wall across the river and have to cross by one or three bridges. They are sitting ducks. And, again, only a very limited number can be deployed in that attack.
  3. The fastest way to get the French out of the city would be to cross the river and march to the southern gates. If the French are not abandoning the city, the batteries placed on the south are going to make staying in it impossible, as was pretty much the case when the French had been storming the city. Well, of course, it can be argued that there already were not too many things to burn but, OTOH, this means that a prolonged staying in it is deadly: there are no shelter for the troops and they are going to die out as soon as the weather turns cold: unlike the Russians, they don’t have access to the winter clothes (part of staying in Tarutino was getting the winter uniforms).
 
Part 12-Nipping at Their Heels
On November 4th, the main body of the Grande Armée began its retreat toawards Minsk. With Davout's I Corps and Saint Cyr's Bavarians forming the rearguard, the French column marched into the Russian countryside. Barclay pursued, and before long both armies were in a race against time to reach the city. The weather turned worse, as one of the coldest winters in Russian history began to settle over the land. Very few soldiers had received their winter clothing, and soon they began to take dratic measures. Many dead from both sides were stripped, in some cases even wounded men were stripped naked and left to freeze, while other troops robbed the already suffering Russian peasants of whatever they had.

Before long the French became increasingly strung out, as many soldiers ignored their officers, and abandoned their units. Barclay kept up the pursuit, but Davout and Saint Cyr were able to fight several sharp rearguard actions, such as at Krasny on the 7th. In two days of desperate fighting, Mortier and the recently recovered Oudinot had to turn about to assist in holding back the Russians, which they did at the cost of 15,000 casualties. Oudinot was yet again seriously wounded, but his actions saved perhaps have the army from destruction.

At the front of the column the last of the French and allied cavalry from Smolensk (Mostly guard cavalry and a handful of ad hoc squadrons) Had to contend with hordes of Cossacks, who hoped to trap the French against one of the rivers they'd have to cross to reach Minsk. However in a standup battle against hardened cuirassiers and dragoons, the lightly armed and unarmored Cossacks were often driven off with heavy losses.

At Borisov, Barclay and Wittgenstein made a final attempt to crush the French, and very nearly suceeded. As the the entire army tried to cross the single bridge over the Berezina river, the Russians hurled themselves at the town with desperate courage. Oudinot and Mortier formed the rearguard, and in the two days it took for the soldiers and stragglers of the strung out force to cross, held the bridge before withdrawing and burning it on the 12th.

Three days later, the exhausted French finally reached Minsk, the 60,000 or so men who had left Minsk and Polotsk having been reduced to 30,000, with another 10,000 stragglers following. They were at least now joined by Ney, Poniatowski, and Grouchy, who had more fresh troops, as well as Augereau's winter supplies. As the cold turned even worse, Barclay decided to be more cautious, as many of his own conscripts were suffering terribly in the cold. This did grant him the ire of the Tsar, but Barclay for once had support from an old critic, General Kutuzov. Having been made the Tsar's new Minister of land forces (Essentially Minister of war) he was now the closest thing the Tsar had to a direct military advisor. He supported Barclay's caution for once, as well as the firing of Admiral Chichagov, who was replaced by General Bennigsen. With the French holed up in Minsk, it was decided to let General Winter go to work...
 
So what were the French losses in Russia in 1812 as compared to OTL?
How many men were lost in the march from Smolensk to Minsk?

How many forces are available to the French in OTL Belarus at the moment?
Are troops going to be marched to Minsk by the end of winter to avoid wasting time in the 1813 campaign?

Why wasn't Courland seized to secure the northern approaches to Minsk?
Was it because of a desire to hold onto Smolensk?

How is the war going on in Spain?
Why is Napoleon feeling confident about pulling troops from Spain?

Had the Minsk Garrison sortied to help the retreat of the Smolensk Garrison, would the result have been any better?

Edit-typo corrected
 
So what were the French losses in Russia in 1812 as compared to OTL?
Slightly better overall, but remember they lost more on the way in than on the way out.
How many men were lost in the march from Smolensk to Minsk?
About 20,000 give of take, more on the give side though..
How many forces are available to the French in OTL Belarus at the moment?
Eh, napkin math says about 60,000 or so, in various conditions however.
Are troops going to be marched to Minsk by the end of winter to avoid wasting time in the 1813 campaign?
That remains to be seen
Why wasn't Courland seized to secure the northern approaches to Minsk?
Was it because of a desire to hold onto Smolensk?
Not quite sure what you mean, the only French forces up there are Macdonald and the Prussians, who are doing about as well as otl.
How is the war going on in Spain?
Why is napoleon feeling confident about pulling troops from Spain?
It's going about the same, no big changes as of yet. He was notably detached from the situation in Spain otl, he didn't really understand how bad things were.
Had the Minsk Garrison stories to help the retreat of the Smolensk Garrison, would the result have been any better?
Maybe, but that also risks them losing Minsk and getting cut off.
 
Top